Parashat Vayera
By Rabbi Ariel Rackovsky
Ask anyone who has worked on a business deal, only for it to fall apart at the last minute over something minor, how infuriated they were. If you’ve been in or set up a relationship that ended over seeming trifles when things got serious, you know how frustrating and counterproductive that can be. Yet that is what happens in an enigmatic story in this week’s Torah reading. Despite our sages including it in the Torah reading on the first day of Rosh Hashanah, I suspect most of us don’t really know why — or what it is even about.
Avimelech, the king of the Philistines and his general Phichol ask Avraham to make a nonaggression pact with them, to which Avraham agrees. Before he signs on the dotted line, though, Avraham reproves Avimelech over the behavior of his servants who seized a well (Genesis 21:22). All he had to do to neutralize a powerful enemy was to promise he would deal honorably with Avimelech and his descendants — something he was likely going to do anyway. And yet he is prepared to torpedo the deal over the behavior of a few of Avimelech’s inconsequential underlings. Isn’t this terrible diplomacy and poor negotiation tactics?
The Netziv, Rav Naftali Tzvi Yehuda Berlin of Volozhin, explains that Avraham was trying to take the measure of the kind of person he would be dealing with. Was he a person of ethics, honor and integrity? How would he react when a subordinate misbehaved or when he was accused of wrongdoing himself? Avimelech’s response told Avraham everything he needed to know.
“Avimelech said, ‘I do not know who did this; you did not tell me, nor have I heard of it until today.’”
This may seem like a needlessly wordy response, but according to the Netziv it was most revealing. Rather than being one repetitive phrase said by one person, it is actually three statements made by three different people. When confronted with the report of the wayward servants at the well, Avimelech said to Avraham, “It wasn’t me — I don’t know who did this.” He then turned to Phichol accusatorily and said, “And you didn’t tell me! You should know what is happening among the soldiers and you should be updating me regularly.” And Phichol replied, “I had faulty intelligence! This is the first I’m hearing of it!”
When confronted with reports of wrongdoing, neither Avimelech nor Phichol took responsibility, choosing instead to point fingers and assign blame to others. In this short exchange, Avraham realized that the person he was dealing with was not someone who accepted responsibility — and he knew he had to be careful.
It is much easier to assign blame, as Avimelech did, than to accept responsibility. Avraham realized that if Avimelech was quick to assign blame, he would eventually be the one blamed. Anyone with even a passing familiarity with world history knows that whenever there is economic uncertainty, societal upheaval or political unrest, fingers are pointed — and we know in which direction, everywhere and without exception. Politics is the natural home of the blame game but it doesn’t stop there.
In our own lives, we assign blame to others for the deficiencies in our character or our circumstances. We all have blame narratives: We would be less angry if everyone around us weren’t so inconsiderate — this is, in one sentence, the premise of Larry David’s behavior in every episode of “Curb Your Enthusiasm.” We would be more patient parents if our children listened to us the first time or if they stopped blaming each other, as kids are wont to do. We would be more learned in Torah and knowledgeable in Judaism if we had been better educated in our formative years or had better teachers.
It is easy to do so because it deflects responsibility from us and prevents us from having to solve our own problems and improve ourselves. Faced with the temptation to point fingers, it would behoove us to recall the words of the prophet Jeremiah in the third chapter of Eichah (3:39):
Of what shall a living man complain? Each one of his own sins!
The lesson of Avraham’s behavior in his treaty with Avimelech presents us with a powerful challenge. Avraham realized that no one ever wins the blame game — not on a national level and not on a personal one. Let us learn from his example so we can better ourselves, accept responsibility and raise our children to do the same.
Rabbi Ariel Rackovsky serves Congregation Shaare Tefila in Dallas. He is a member of the Rabbinic Association of Greater Dallas.
