By Laura Seymour
Editor’s note
This summer, the Shabbat Lady is challenging your family to study the Talmudic tractate known as Pirke Avot, Chapters of the Sages. Pirke Avot is comprised of six chapters and more than 150 mishnahyot, or teachings. With JCC summer camp keeping her busy for nine weeks, the Shabbat Lady has prepared a mishnah for each week. Spend time each Shabbat talking about the mishnah using the questions below as a guide.
Begin by reading the words, then break down the parts — and trust that even young children can contribute meaningful thoughts to the discussion. Listening to one another is the beginning of learning.
Dear Families,
Another mishnah from Hillel!
For each mishnah, the speaker is named. Why is it important to know who said something? I’ve always believed this was how copyright laws came about — we must give credit to the one who first shared an idea. Amazing that it started in the Talmud!
Hillel says:
Do not separate yourself from the community;
do not judge your fellow until you have reached his place;
and do not say, “When I have time I will study,”
for perhaps you will not have time.
— Pirke Avot 2:5
Questions to ask
- Hillel gave us so many important lessons. At first, they seem simple, but we must continue to look deeper and apply them to our lives. Judaism teaches that being part of a community is very important. What are the different communities you belong to? How are they different, and how are they the same?
- Why shouldn’t we separate ourselves from our community? What are some ways people unintentionally (or intentionally) do that?
- Last week, we talked about judging others. It’s something we all do — but not always in the right way. Now Hillel says: Do not judge someone until you have reached their place. What does it mean to be in someone’s place? If we haven’t been in their place, should we still judge them? Why or why not?
- Study is a central value in Jewish life. We are taught to keep learning throughout our lives — not just until we finish school. Why is continued learning important in Judaism? What are ways adults keep learning?
- Hillel warns: Don’t say you’ll study later — you might not have time. Why might we think we’ll have time later when we don’t? What gets in the way?
- These three lessons — community, judging others and study — are all in one mishnah. Why do you think Hillel connected them? Can you picture someone who separates from the community, judges others and doesn’t study? What kind of person is that? Why might that be a problem?
- How can we apply this mishnah to our everyday lives? What changes might we make in how we act, think or spend our time?
Laura Seymour is Jewish experiential learning director and camp director emeritus at the Aaron Family JCC.
