By Rabbi Yerachmiel D. Fried
Dear Rabbi Fried,
I am contemplating entering into a real estate partnership agreement with another Jew. I wonder what type of exit strategies should be formulated in advance, just in case it doesn’t work out. Or would we be governed by Jewish law, in any event? Are there Jewish laws concerning the dissolution of partnerships?
Mel Z.
Dear Mel,
I will provide you with a thumbnail sketch of some of the Jewish laws concerning dissolving a partnership, as outlined by the Code of Jewish Law.
One partner has the right to dissolve a partnership, even if the other partner objects that it would cause him a loss. This is a complicated issue, and we cannot give it full treatment here. But when the partners choose to dissolve the partnership, they must follow certain guidelines in Jewish law.
There are various methods of dissolving a partnership:
The first option is to share the business’s inventory equally among the partners — for example, distributing vacant lots equally, assuming they are identical in value. If they are not identical, each lot could be divided into sections, if that does not significantly diminish functionality or value.
If the functionality or value would be diminished, there is a process called Gud Agud — “I take all or you take all” — where one partner buys out the other. The party that initiates the Gud Agud proposes a value for the business. The other partner then chooses to either accept the buyout offer at that price or buy the initiating partner’s share for the same amount. The price may not be below the true market value of the business. The initiating party must have the financial ability to perform the buyout, and the other party has 30 days to execute it if they so choose.
Another possibility is for the properties to be rented out, with the partners sharing the proceeds. If one partner wants to rent it all, he has the right to do so. If both wish to rent it, a Gud Agud could also be done on the rental rights.
Lastly, the partners could alternate use of the entire property by a mutually agreed-upon dissolution policy.
These are the general principles. However, because the laws of dividing a partnership can be complex, it is strongly advisable to negotiate a mechanism for dissolution before entering into a partnership agreement.
In all cases, one should consult a halachic authority — an experienced dayan (rabbinic judge) who is an expert in monetary law. This will ensure a fair and mutually agreed-upon solution that protects both parties and upholds both halacha and civil law.
The laws of Torah are timeless. Torah is not merely ritual — it is a comprehensive way of life. All areas of our lives, including business matters, are infused with the sanctity of Torah and find guidance in its principles.
Rabbi Yerachmiel Fried is the dean of Dallas Area Torah Association.
