By Laura Seymour
Dear Families,
Have you started shopping for Passover? Yes, it is time, and shopping and cleaning are an important part, but the most important question is what there is to learn each year as we repeat the same story and follow the same rituals. First of all, there is always something new to learn, and second, even familiar rituals can take on new meaning.
The story of Passover appears in the Haggadah; however, it does not include everything found in the Book of Exodus and beyond. I like to have my Tanakh plus a variety of commentaries on Exodus and Passover ready for the many questions that sometimes come up as we challenge ourselves to see the story fresh with meaning for today. One of the interesting facts about the Haggadah is that Moses has a very minor role in it (some Haggadahs don’t even mention his name). An old book (1999 — yes, that is old) by David Baron with Lynette Padwa, “Moses on Management – 50 Leadership Lessons from the Greatest Manager of All Time,” has become my new go-to book on management. The Torah is filled with advice on all subjects, and leadership definitely has many role models to look to for guidance today.
Moses was a reluctant leader, taking on an enormous task that he didn’t really want or feel confident to take on. However, with a push from above, he is thrust into monumental challenges with a group that was beyond difficult. What can we learn from him? The chapters in Baron’s book are lessons for everyone leading a group. A quick search for “leadership vs. management” gives this definition:
Leadership is more about driving change, while management is about executing change. Leadership is about thinking ahead and capitalizing on opportunities, whereas management is about implementing processes to achieve organizational goals. Leaders inspire their teams, encouraging growth and vision, while managers emphasize structure, coordination and operational harmony. Leadership is the ability to motivate a group of people to work toward a common goal, whereas management is the systematic process of planning, organizing and controlling things or people.
Think about Moses and ask the questions above. Did he drive change or execute change? Did he think ahead or take things as they came? Was he an inspiring leader? Did he motivate the people to work together? We can certainly have a good discussion on how effective Moses was and where he may have fallen short. Yet one important question is: Did he grow into the job?
Often we are put into a position that we are not ready for, and hopefully we learn and succeed. Baron asks in his book whether a headhunter today would have given Moses the job based on his experience. What was it that G-d saw in Moses that led to him being chosen for the job? One thing we know from learning Torah and reading about our biblical heroes is that you don’t have to be perfect, and sometimes you must go with the flow. Moses made mistakes but did not give up. Many of us question why hitting the rock led to a punishment that seems unfair, yet maybe G-d forced a succession plan for a leader who needed to pass on the role of leadership.
As you prepare for your seder discussions, plan for a conversation on leadership. Remember that the lessons of the past are meant to guide the future.
Laura Seymour is Jewish Experiential Learning director and Camp director emeritus at the Aaron Family JCC.
