Reincarnation and dreams

By Rabbi Yerachmiel D. Fried

Dear Rabbi Fried,

Does reincarnation explain why it is believed that we were all at Mt. Sinai to receive the Torah? Secondly, how do you explain dreams — for example, Holocaust dreams? Is it a window into a previous life or just your imagination? What about when people who have died visit you in a dream? Is that your imagination or something more — does that mean their soul is now back on earth?

— Annie

Dear Annie,

Technically, reincarnation, as the term implies, refers to the return of a soul to a second corporeal body after it has already occupied a first. It does not refer to the soul’s original entry into a body.

The Sages teach that all Jewish souls were present at Mt. Sinai to participate in the acceptance of the Torah by the entire Jewish people for all time. In this way, all Jewish souls — even those later endowed into Jewish bodies throughout history — are included in the national and individual responsibility to uphold and fulfill the Torah.

Since most of those souls had not yet been enclosed in physical bodies at the time, the concept of “reincarnation” would not technically apply. The souls present at Sinai were “stand-alone” — not yet partnered with bodies, which is typically a prerequisite for Torah study and the fulfillment of mitzvot. However, this presence at Sinai demonstrates the soul’s capacity to receive missions and messages for future relevance once it becomes embodied. This concept forms the foundation for the idea of reincarnation.

The notion of dreams in Judaism is multifaceted. The Talmud and Kabbalistic writings describe numerous categories of dreams. Some, particularly for individuals on an elevated spiritual level, can serve as a form of divine inspiration, offering nearly prophetic insight or intuition. There have been rabbis, rebbetzins and other deeply spiritual individuals who have received profound Torah concepts through their dreams — in some cases, on a regular basis.

This idea connects to a deeper understanding of sleep itself: a time of partial detachment of the soul from the body, allowing the soul to “recharge” in heavenly realms. While in that higher state, the soul may access insights unavailable in its usual physical condition.

The Talmud and other sources speak of rare visitations in dreams by departed loved ones or rabbis, often to deliver messages — sometimes even to protect the dreamer from harm. There are specific liturgical formulas in the Talmud and Siddur designed to process troubling or ominous dreams. One especially meaningful prayer, HaMapil, often recited during Birkat Kohanim (the priestly blessing in the repetition of the Musaf service on holidays), asks for dreams to be “sweetened” — transforming any negative dream experiences “from curses into blessings.”

There are also many documented anecdotes of dreams in which vivid, personal details were revealed about deceased individuals — information known only to the person who passed away. These experiences lend credibility to the concept of reincarnation and have been studied by both psychologists and spiritual researchers.

However, the Sages caution that most of our dreams today are simply the product of our daily thoughts, what we’ve read or heard, or our imaginations set loose by the freedom of sleep. In those cases, dreams should not be taken seriously or cause concern.

Pleasant dreams!

Sincerely,

Rabbi Yerachmiel Fried

Rabbi Yerachmiel Fried is the dean of Dallas Area Torah Association.

Leave a Reply