Understanding cannot come at reality’s expense

GUEST COLUMN

By Mahra Pailet 

In her opinion piece, “The danger of fear-driven rhetoric,” in last week’s Texas Jewish Post (April 23), Jaynie Schultz urges readers to approach difficult topics with the tried-and-true Stephen Covey principle of “seek first to understand, then to be understood.” It is a thoughtful and constructive framework, one that encourages empathy, nuance and restraint in an increasingly polarized environment.

But understanding, to be meaningful, must be grounded in a full and honest assessment of reality. When it comes to analyzing concerns about Islamists who seek to build communities in Texas and Florida — the two major “gets” among those seeking U.S. strongholds — as a means of gaining a population foothold and eventually influencing local politics, while also pointing to rising antisemitism and violent anti-Zionism, many believe those concerns are both measurable and deeply troubling.

Schultz cautions against rhetoric that invokes concepts such as “Islamization” or frequent references to Sharia law, suggesting that such language can inflame fear and distort perception. She is right that careless or sweeping generalizations about entire communities are harmful and counterproductive. Jews experience that harm daily. However, the challenge lies in distinguishing between broad, unfounded fear and legitimate concern about specific ideologies and their real-world consequences.

Applying the maxim of seeking first to understand in this case requires acknowledging not only the importance of interfaith respect, but also the existence of extremist interpretations within Islamist movements that explicitly promote hostility toward Jews. These views do not represent all Muslims, nor should they be used to generalize about a diverse global faith. But they do exist, and in many cases, they have been directly linked to acts of violence and incitement. Ignoring this dimension in the interest of avoiding “fear-driven rhetoric” risks oversimplifying a complex and serious issue.

The data reinforces why concern is not merely rhetorical. According to the Anti-Defamation League, antisemitic incidents in the United States reached record levels in 2024, with more than 9,000 reported cases, including physical assaults, vandalism and harassment. Jews continue to be disproportionately targeted in religion-based hate crimes. Globally, similar patterns have emerged, particularly following the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attacks, with spikes in antisemitic incidents reported across Europe, Australia and North America.

These developments are not abstract. They affect daily life: increased security at synagogues, Jewish students feeling unsafe on campuses and individuals facing harassment for visible expressions of their identity. To frame concern about these realities as primarily the product of fear-driven rhetoric risks dismissing the lived experiences of those directly affected.

Schultz’s call for empathy and understanding is important, but it must be applied consistently. Just as we are asked to understand the diversity within Muslim communities and avoid conflation, we must also understand the concerns of Jews without dismissing them as exaggerated or reactionary. The principle cuts both ways.

There is also an important distinction between criticism of Israeli policy and rhetoric that crosses into antisemitism. Political disagreement is legitimate and necessary. However, when language denies Jews self-determination in their historic homeland, demonizes Jews collectively or justifies violence against Jewish civilians, it ceases to be political critique. Increasingly, data suggests that a significant portion of antisemitic incidents today are tied to rhetoric framed through hostility toward Israel or Zionism.

I learned a long time ago that people often reveal who they are if we are willing to listen. When synagogues are attacked, Jewish men and women are assaulted and rockets are launched at Israel from multiple fronts, actions speak louder than words — though the words themselves have often been clear. For many in our community, slogans such as “from the river to the sea,” campus encampments and the influence of foreign funding contribute to a growing sense of concern.

The danger, then, is not simply fear-driven rhetoric; it is the failure to fully acknowledge uncomfortable facts. When discourse focuses solely on the risks of overreaction without equally addressing real threats and hateful objectives, it creates an imbalance that hinders honest discussion.

Words do matter. They shape perceptions, influence behavior and can either build bridges or deepen divides. But so does omission. Failing to acknowledge the scale and nature of antisemitism and anti-Zionism today does not reduce fear; it risks leaving communities unprepared and unsupported.

If we are to truly seek first to understand, we must be willing to confront uncomfortable truths alongside calls for empathy. Only then can understanding lead to meaningful dialogue — and dialogue to solutions that are both just and grounded in reality.

Mahra Pailet is a Dallas Jewish community leader and Israel advocate.

Leave a Reply