By Rabbi Yosef Pinkus
Dear Rabbi,
I have heard people say that there are rabbinic laws and Torah laws. What’s the difference, and why does it matter?
— Ben W.
Dear Ben,
Like any legal system, Torah law has many different categories and, for most onlookers, they are very confusing. The confusion arises because the rabbis of the Talmud, by and large, performed two separate jobs, and people often conflate them.
The first job was like a lawyer interpreting a contract by clarifying and defining the various details of Torah-level law. For example, when the Torah commands us to take a “beautiful fruit” (pri etz hadar) on Sukkot, it doesn’t specify which fruit. Through intense scrutiny of the biblical text and traditions passed down through the oral law, the rabbis clarified that this refers to an etrog. There are further details explained by the rabbis, such as that the etrog may not contain a blemish. When the rabbis defined these details, they were simply clarifying a preexisting Torah-level obligation, extracting what was already there, not inventing something new.
The second job was entirely different. The rabbis also acted as legislators, creating new laws known as takkanot or gezerot. These were not intended to clarify Torah-level matters but instead were new obligations that served a variety of reasons. Most commonly they served as a buffer zone. By strengthening the overall practice, one could come to distance oneself from sin, as it says in “Ethics of the Fathers,” “Make a fence around the Torah.”
When the Sanhedrin was functioning and there was sufficient unity among the Jewish people, these courts could establish new rules and regulations — though there were, in fact, many checks and balances on this process. These laws have a categorically different status in Jewish law than the details of Torah law they clarified.
Here’s a practical example of why the distinctions between these two different jobs matter. Someone who is ill on Shabbat may take Tylenol because the restriction against taking medicine is merely rabbinically legislated. The reason behind the medicinal prohibition is that there are often associated problems with the creation of medicine — the measuring or the crushing of ingredients and the like. If it were a Torah-level restriction, or even a detail extracted by the rabbis through interpretation, however, taking the Tylenol would not be allowed.
Understanding these different categories of halachah is crucial for clarifying where each law came from and what role it plays. In fact, much of what the Talmud is consumed with is clarifying and detailing all these myriad little details: where they came from, what their source is and so forth.
Rabbi Yosef Pinkus is a rabbi in the Dallas Community Kollel, a division of the Dallas Area Torah Association. Submit your questions to him at asktherabbi@tjpnews.com.
